Home » News & Articles » 2024 » New study shows ‘biodiversity boost’ planning policy needs to improve metric to reflect the intricacies of ecosystems

New study shows ‘biodiversity boost’ planning policy needs to improve metric to reflect the intricacies of ecosystems

Research Fellow Cicely Marshall hopes the results of her study will help improve the way nature’s value is calculated and translate into real-life gains for birds and butterflies as the UK plans to build 300,000 homes a year by mid-2020.
Cicely Marshall surveying farmland. © Jill Marshall

From 2024, the UK’s Environment Act requires planning applications to demonstrate an overall biodiversity net gain of at least 10% as calculated using a new statutory biodiversity metric. But this new legal requirement for developers to demonstrate a biodiversity boost in planning applications could make a more meaningful impact on nature recovery if improvements are made to the way nature’s value is calculated, say researchers at the University of Cambridge.

The researchers trialled the metric by using it to calculate the biodiversity value of 24 sites across England. These sites have all been monitored over the long-term, allowing the team to compare biodiversity species data with results from the metric.

Plant biodiversity at the sites matched values produced using the metric, but bird and butterfly biodiversity did not, which means there’s no evidence that a 10% net biodiversity gain calculated using the statutory biodiversity metric will translate into real-life gains for birds and butterflies, without additional conservation management.

This is the first comprehensive study of the performance of Defra’s statutory biodiversity metric across England. The research was funded by the Ecological Continuity Trust and results have now been published in the Journal of Applied Ecology.

Dr Cicely Marshall, Research Fellow at King’s and first author of the paper, says

"The statutory biodiversity metric is a really important opportunity, and has potential to direct a lot of money into biodiversity conservation from developers. It’s the responsibility of conservationists and policy makers to ensure that it provides a reliable indication of nature’s diversity. At the moment the metric does capture plant diversity quite well, but it doesn’t reflect the intricacies of ecosystems – species like birds and butterflies use habitats in very different ways.

Many property developments have been very detrimental to nature in the past, and it’s exciting that England now has a requirement for developers to leave nature in a better state than they found it.”

The UK is committed to building 300,000 homes a year by mid-2020, so the net biodiversity gain requirement is expected to generate a market for biodiversity credits worth an estimated £135m-£274m annually – substantially increasing funding for nature conservation in England.

Read more about this new study here

Similar Entries


Study shows the impact of the King's wildflower meadow

Published today, the study led by King’s Research Fellow Cicely Marshall shows that establishing the meadow has made a considerable impact to the wildlife value of the land, while reducing the greenhouse gas emissions associated with its upkeep.


Biodiversity paper from King’s PhD student published

The study carried out by Ash Simkins examines human developments in important sites for biodiversity.


Biodiversity survey under way in wildflower meadow

Research is currently being conducted to monitor the impact of the meadow in preventing the decline of pollinating insects.


Research examines impact of tourism and climate change on Antarctic biodiversity

College Research Associate Jasmine Lee’s research focuses on the impact of human activity, non-native species, pollution, and climate change on Antarctica. 


Finding new ways to improve cancer immunotherapies: rethinking Treg cell targeting

New study co-authored by King’s CRA Dr Sarah Whiteside explores how conventional CD4+ T cells hinder cancer immunotherapies targeting Treg cells.


Sustainable Travel Policy encouraging use of low-emission transport

The policy offers additional funding for travelling by sustainable modes and involves carbon-offsetting where flying is unavoidable.


Biodiversity survey in the wildflower meadow

Dozens of pollinators, invertebrates and plant species have been identified in the meadow


Hydrological study under way in River Cam

The study will monitor river temperatures with a view to reducing the College's carbon footprint.

Follow us on Instagram

View more